
The client has escalated.
A deadline has been missed.
Your team is waiting for your response.
You are disappointed. Perhaps angry. You may be facing questions from your own leadership.
What do you say first?
“Who allowed this to happen?”
“Why am I hearing about this now?”
Or:
“Tell me what we know—and what needs our attention immediately.”
You may need to ask all three questions eventually.
But the order, tone and intention behind them matter.
It is easy to describe our leadership values when things are going well.
The harder test is how we practise them when something goes wrong.
From giving ownership to responding under pressure
In the first article of Leadership Beyond the Workshop, we explored the shift from giving answers to building judgment.
In the second, we examined accountability without fear: clear expectations, meaningful support and consistent follow-through.
Now comes the moment that tests both.
Someone has used their judgment. They have taken responsibility. And the outcome is not what anyone wanted.
What happens next?
Do we take every decision back?
Do we make an example of the person?
Or do we address the situation firmly while keeping the opportunity to learn and take ownership alive?
To me, this is where leadership moves beyond intention and becomes visible behaviour.
Your first response is not the whole conversation
When something goes wrong, there are usually several jobs to do:
We do not have to do all of them in the first thirty seconds.
Consider a team member who says:
“I have sent the client the wrong version of the proposal.”
An immediate response might be:
“How could you be so careless?”
There may indeed have been a lapse in care. But that statement does not tell us which document was sent, whether the client has acted on it or what correction is needed.
A more useful opening is:
“Which version went out? What is different? Has the client responded?”
This is not avoiding accountability.
It is putting the immediate problem before the judgment.
There will be time to examine the decision. First, we need to understand and address its consequences.
A practical approach: Pause, Understand, Respond
From a coaching and training perspective, I suggest practising three moves.
Not as a rigid script, but as a way to bring intention into a pressured moment.
A pause does not have to mean a long silence.
It may be one breath before speaking.
A moment to separate:
“I am frustrated by this outcome.”
from:
“This person needs to feel my frustration.”
Ask yourself:
“What does this situation need from me first?”
It may need an urgent decision. A clear instruction. A question. Or simply your full attention.
You can be direct without being personal:
“This is serious. Our immediate priority is to correct it.”
Pausing is not a delay in leadership. It is a chance to choose how you lead.
Before deciding what the incident says about someone, establish what actually happened.
Useful questions include:
Listen for the distinction between an explanation and a verified fact.
“The client is furious” may mean the client has expressed anger.
Or it may mean someone is worried about how the client will react.
Those are different situations.
Understanding also means hearing the person involved—not only the people describing their actions.
The aim is not to gather enough information to confirm your first impression. It is to form a sound view of the situation.
Once the immediate picture is clear, move to action.
Agree:
For example:
“You will prepare the corrected proposal. I will speak to the client about the error. Before anything is sent, we will review the changes together. Let’s reconnect at 2 p.m.”
That is direction with ownership.
The team member remains involved in putting things right. The leader provides the support and decisions the situation requires.
Two conversations—not one emotional exchange
I find it useful to distinguish the recovery conversation from the learning conversation.
The recovery conversation
“What do we need to do now?”
Its focus is the immediate impact, the next action and the people affected.
The learning conversation
“What do we need to understand and change?”
Its focus is the decisions, conditions and behaviours that contributed to the outcome.
These conversations may happen close together. In a simple situation, they may be part of one discussion.
But separating their purposes helps prevent an urgent problem-solving meeting from becoming a public interrogation.
Once the situation is stable, return to questions such as:
“What did you notice at the time?”
“What influenced your decision?”
“Where could we have checked or escalated?”
“What will you do differently?”
“What do I need to change as your leader?”
That last question matters.
We cannot ask others to examine their contribution while leaving our own outside the discussion.
Do not turn every mistake into a coaching exercise
There are situations where immediate instruction, escalation or formal action is necessary.
A safety incident, a serious compliance concern or deliberate misconduct should be handled through the appropriate organizational process.
And someone facing an unfamiliar, urgent problem may need expertise—not a series of questions.
“Tell me what you think” is not always the most helpful response.
The coaching opportunity may come later:
“Here is what we need to do now. Once the immediate issue is addressed, we will review how to handle this next time.”
The intention is not to coach at every moment.
It is to use judgment about when to direct, when to support and when to explore.
Practise the moment—not just the principle
In leadership training, “stay calm under pressure” is easy to agree with.
It is more useful to practise what we will actually say.
Here is a simple exercise for your next leadership session.
Give participants a scenario:
A client has complained about a commitment your team cannot meet. You learn that the warning signs were visible two days ago, but nobody escalated them.
Ask each participant to write their first two sentences.
Then examine them:
Practise again, this time using Pause, Understand, Respond.
The goal is not to sound polished in a classroom.
It is to prepare for a conversation that may otherwise be driven entirely by frustration.
The standard you set when it is difficult
Leadership does not require us to be untroubled by mistakes.
We can be disappointed. We can be firm. We can expect better.
But we are still responsible for how we express those expectations.
And if we get our own response wrong, we can return to it:
“My tone earlier was not appropriate. The issue still needs to be addressed, but I should have handled that conversation differently.”
That does not remove the standard.
It demonstrates that the standard applies to us too.
This week, notice your first response when something goes wrong.
Before asking, “How could this happen?”, consider asking:
“What needs our attention first?”
Then return to responsibility and learning. Do not leave either behind.
The leadership test is not whether you feel pressure.
It is whether your response serves the situation—or simply releases the pressure you feel.
What are the first words your team hears from you when the news is not good?
Newsletter – 13th Edition
© The Redwood Edge 2025